Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Quiara Vasquez's avatar

I think the thing that makes me so annoyed about Barbie is that, like... why isn't this film for kids? Do Gerwig and Baumbach think a kids' movie has to be shit? Have they not watched the Toy Stories? Shit, why not go to the multiplex right now and watch Spiderverse 2? Do they not know you can make a genuinely good, emotionally affecting, artistically innovative movie that's also high-key a toy commercial meant for five-year-olds? To tailor the film so strongly to the 35+ demo is to concede defeat before the first frame IMHO.

So I guess I share your linked article's frustration with children's books - I don't know where kids are supposed to turn these days for stuff in the vein of Gorey or The Phantom Tollbooth or even Goosebumps, the sort of stuff I just devoured as a child. And I like you have thought about writing books for kids - except I have your opposite problem, where I have some modicum of artistic talent but no ideas, LOL. (Perhaps this is the beginning of a beautiful friendship? Does Substack have DMs? :P)

Expand full comment
William Collen's avatar

Appreciated the link about children's books. As a father I can attest to my own kids' not caring one bit about the sentimental, "In Grandma's Garden" / "The Giving Tree" type of picture books. Instead they will go to the library and check out every book they can find on, for example, unicorns, or apples, or excavators. It's almost like they are doing research of some kind.

They've written books of their own; usually these books have absolutely no plot and are indescribably silly. So that is one data point in favor of the author's conclusion that kids should be allowed to look at things their own way.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts